Refinement Orders for Quantitative Information Flow and Differential Privacy †

Quantitative Information Flow (QIF) and Differential Privacy (DP) are both concerned with the protection of sensitive information, but they are rather different approaches. In particular, QIF considers the expected probability of a successful attack, while DP (in both its standard and local versions) is a max-case measure, in the sense that it is compromised by the existence of a possible attack, regardless of its probability. Comparing systems is a fundamental task in these areas: one wishes to guarantee that replacing a system A by a system B is a safe operation that is the privacy of B is no worse than that of A. In QIF, a refinement order provides strong such guarantees, while, in DP, mechanisms are typically compared w.r.t. the privacy parameter (Formula presented.) in their definition. In this paper, we explore a variety of refinement orders, inspired by the one of QIF, providing precise guarantees for max-case leakage. We study simple structural ways of characterising them, the relation between them, efficient methods for verifying them and their lattice properties. Moreover, we apply these orders in the task of comparing DP mechanisms, raising the question of whether the order based on (Formula presented.) provides strong privacy guarantees. We show that, while it is often the case for mechanisms of the same “family” (geometric, randomised response, etc.), it rarely holds across different families.